Galatea is a short story by Madeline Miller, written after The Song of Achilles and in the middle of her working on Circe. As an expert in classics and a teacher in Latin and Greek at high schools, Miller is surely expected to draw her inspiration from their host of works. This time it’s Metamorphoses by Ovid―a classic hailed by many as a romantic, happy-ever-after love story but, to Miller herself, has a disturbingly misogynistic undercurrent in it. Hence the need not only to retell but to twist it.
Unlike Circe, which is a retelling but still in the mythical world, Galatea seems to be a blend of everything. It’s a classic with mythological elements set in our modern narrative―which, as we can see it widely in almost every aspect and any sense, is not that much different from that of the ancient times.
The story starts with, and this might raise a question in any reader’s mind, Galatea being and waking up in a closed room with only a nurse attending her and a doctor who regularly checks up on her. She is confined in bed, she must lie down, and every time she suggests an idea of her taking a walk outside to warm herself in response to the nurse and the doctor finding her body too cold, they banish it immediately. The reason is―it seems likely so―none other than their being afraid of her husband, besides being paid by him.
As for the motive behind this confinement, though, it is not clear until Miller takes us through the already known narrative by Ovid, which serves as the backstory. Galatea was a statue, “born” out of an ivory, and the man sculpted her eventually married her when she came to life. They have a daughter, Paphos, who is smart and rebellious and has no qualms about saying no to her tyrant of a father. And Paphos’ smartness is not enough for a governess, so Galatea asks her husband for another tutor (the previous one was sacked for looking at her, which her husband detested). And, of course, her husband refuses the idea.
Unfortunately, if you want to say so, Paphos is not a daddy’s girl and, unlike her obedient mother, cannot be confined in anything by anybody. When she is not allowed to go outside and learn more she is restless, up to the point of not caring if she disturbs her father working at home with her behavior. So Galatea, who loves her daughter so much that even her husband is jealous of her, takes her to the countryside to play just as they usually did. Galatea tells Paphos not to tell her father, for he will surely be very angry should he know; and then, together, they walk out on the street as secretly as they can. But they are too conspicuous―with their looking “as pale as milk” and Galatea herself is an obvious, outstanding beauty that makes her husband wary and anxious and keen on keeping her from anybody else. Long story short, they are caught, and this is why Galatea is consequently punished.
Galatea, as a story, is not being subtle. It tells the reader loud and clear that there are always disturbing ideas about women in society―either it’s ancient or modern. Ideas that the most perfect woman (wife?) is the one with a perfect, outstanding beauty, moral purity and total obedience; that if a man kiss you and you’re not blushing then you are shameless; that any (other) man cannot look at you when you are strikingly pretty; that your sole and only function as a woman is to bear and rear children for your husband and to satisfy his sexual needs. A pretty woman in a cage, full stop. Nothing else.
These ideas have taken root for generations and no amount of protests, negation, or feminist movements could pull them out or even, at the very least, prevent them from spreading wider. They do not apply to everybody, yes, but still, they exist in almost every culture we know, in almost every society there is. If this is a strong enough reason for some (many?) women to feel angry, then it is justifiable. If this is a strong enough reason for Miller to sound angry in her writing, then it is justifiable. Galatea’s voice is as calm as she seems obedient, but her rage is there and profound. She looks like a “yes, Sir” wife but she is not stupid, and the dissatisfaction with her caged life is secretly seething until finally she chooses her own way.
Madeline Miller’s Galatea is merely a short retelling, but its twist is impactful. And what makes it even more relevant (today) is not only our constant need to rebel against something which is badly against our will, but also our need to state firmly that these ideas cannot go on any longer.
Rating: 4.5/5